Title: Can Global Development Succeed Without Human Rights in Pakistan?
By Ehsan ullah
In recent years, Pakistan has invested heavily in development — building roads, expanding infrastructure, attracting foreign investment, and partnering with global institutions on education and health. On paper, this progress reflects a country eager to modernize and integrate with the global economy. But behind the statistics lies a more uncomfortable truth: development in Pakistan continues to advance without securing the rights and dignity of its most vulnerable citizens.
The contradiction is stark. While shiny new motorways and metro buses showcase economic ambition, thousands of communities remain without clean water, basic education, or access to fair legal protection. In some areas, development has deepened inequality, favoring urban elites while leaving rural populations — particularly in Balochistan, Sindh, and parts of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa — in chronic neglect.
The issue is not development itself, but the model Pakistan is following. Global development partners, including the World Bank, Asian Development Bank, and UN agencies, have poured billions into Pakistan’s economy. These investments have produced visible improvements: better roads, expanded healthcare programs, and more schools. International donors have also supported gender-focused reforms, including legislation on harassment and child protection.
However, many of these efforts operate in isolation from the political and social realities on the ground. For example, building schools is meaningless if girls cannot safely attend due to threats or harmful customs. Expanding the internet is valuable, but not if journalists and human rights activists are silenced online through intimidation or legal harassment.
In recent years, space for civil society in Pakistan has narrowed significantly. Journalists have faced increasing restrictions, from formal censorship to informal pressure. Human rights defenders have been detained, disappeared, or targeted online. Religious minorities continue to face systemic discrimination, and laws like the blasphemy law are frequently misused, often with deadly consequences.
These are not side issues — they go to the heart of what true development means. Development that ignores human rights is not progress, it is performance.
This disconnect is further compounded by the politics of international aid. Many development programs come tied to conditions that prioritize macroeconomic stability or privatization, often ignoring grassroots realities. Poor communities are sometimes displaced to make room for large-scale infrastructure, with no compensation or legal recourse. In these cases, global development ends up reinforcing existing injustices rather than addressing them.
Women, too, are caught in this paradox. While donor-funded campaigns encourage female empowerment, millions of women remain excluded from the workforce, face domestic violence, or are denied access to justice. Laws may exist, but enforcement is weak, especially in conservative or conflict-affected areas. Development slogans ring hollow when women continue to be treated as second-class citizens in daily life.
Pakistan’s legal and judicial systems are another critical gap. Without strong, independent institutions to protect rights, even the best-funded development projects will fail to achieve lasting change. Courts are often slow, police lack accountability, and political interference remains common. Until governance is reformed, development will continue to benefit the few at the expense of the many.
What Pakistan needs now is a rights-based development model — one that integrates human dignity, equality, and justice into every stage of planning and implementation. This means putting people before profit, ensuring participation from affected communities, and holding both state and non-state actors accountable for abuses.
International donors also have a role to play. They must move beyond simply measuring success in numbers and begin evaluating their impact on people’s rights and freedoms. Funding programs that contribute to injustice — even unintentionally — undermines the very purpose of development aid.
Pakistan has the potential to be a model for inclusive, democratic development in the Global South. But this will not happen unless the government and its partners commit to prioritizing human rights alongside economic goals.
Without justice, there can be no true progress. And without rights, development is just another form of inequality — dressed in new infrastructure and wrapped in borrowed funds.
Ehsan ullah is a freelance writer and researcher focused on global development, democracy, and human rights in South Asia. He has previously published articles in leading Pakistani newspapers.
Warm regards,
Ehsan ullah
03490251869
https://www.linkedin.com/in/ehsandanish
Author: Ehsan ullah in Northern Pakistan
